top of page
Search

What to Know About Metal Roofs If You're Buying (or Already Own) One in Central New York

Writer: Benjamin Augustine
Benjamin Augustine
Oct 30
4 min read


I probably inspect more metal roofs every winter than I did five years ago. They've gotten popular around here for a good reason — and it's a reason that has everything to do with our weather. But a metal roof isn't a "install it and forget it forever" thing, no matter what the salesman told the last owner. Here's what I actually look at up on the roof, and what I think every CNY homeowner should know.


Why Metal Roofs Make Sense in Our Climate

Between the lake-effect snow we get off Lake Ontario, the freeze-thaw cycles every homeowner from Oswego to Cortland knows too well, and the ice damming that wrecks so many asphalt shingle roofs around here, metal has some real advantages:


  • Snow sheds instead of sitting. A properly installed metal roof lets heavy snow slide off rather than piling up and adding load. This matters a lot in our snowbelt towns.

  • Ice dams are less common — not impossible. Metal doesn't stop ice dams on its own; that's about attic insulation and ventilation more than roofing material. But metal's smooth surface and typically better installation practices (more attention to underlayment) tend to reduce the problem.

  • Longevity. A quality standing seam metal roof can run 40-70 years. Compare that to 20-25 years for a typical asphalt shingle roof in our climate, where freeze-thaw cycling is hard on shingles.

  • Wind and hail resistance. Metal generally holds up better than asphalt in the wind events we get off the lakes.

That said, "metal roof" isn't one product. What's actually on the house matters a lot.


The Two Types I See Most Often Around CNY


Standing seam. Long, vertical panels with raised seams that interlock, and no exposed fasteners. This is the higher-end system, typically installed by a specialty roofer, and it's what I'd call the gold standard for snow country. Concealed fasteners mean fewer places for water to find its way in over time.


Screw-down (exposed fastener) panels. Corrugated or ribbed panels fastened directly through the metal with exposed screws and rubber washers. This is the more affordable option, and it's common on garages, barns, and budget re-roofs. It works fine, but it has a real weak point I check closely: those rubber washers under every screw head degrade over time — usually somewhere in the 10-20 year range — and once they do, that's where the leaks start.


If you're buying a home and the disclosure just says "metal roof," it's worth asking which type it is before you assume you've got 50 years of no-maintenance roofing ahead of you.


What I Actually Check on a Metal Roof Inspection


Fastener condition (screw-down systems). I'm looking at whether the washers are still sealing tight or showing cracking, and whether any screws are backed out or overdriven — both cause leaks.

Seams and flashing. Where the roof meets a chimney, a dormer, or a wall, that's where metal roofs most often fail. I pay close attention to step flashing and any place a seam was cut or pieced around a penetration.

Oil canning. This is the wavy, rippled look you sometimes see in the flat parts of metal panels. It's usually cosmetic — a byproduct of how the metal was rolled or installed — but I note it because it's sometimes mistaken by buyers for structural trouble.

Rust and dissimilar metal corrosion. If a roof has steel components in contact with copper or aluminum flashing (common around vents and chimneys), you can get galvanic corrosion where the two metals meet. I flag any spot where this is starting.

Fastening into the right substrate. I check whether panels are fastened into solid decking or furring strips and whether that structure shows any soft spots, especially around older re-roofs where metal was installed right over existing shingles.

Underlayment and condensation control. Metal roofs need proper underlayment (ice and water shield in our climate especially) and attic ventilation, or you can get condensation forming on the underside of the panels — which looks like a leak but isn't coming from outside at all.

Snow retention systems. If the home has a walkway, deck, or entry door directly below a metal roof slope, I check whether snow guards or a snow retention system is installed. Without them, a metal roof can shed an entire winter's snow load in one avalanche-style slide — genuinely dangerous if it's coming down over a porch or driveway people use.


A Few Things Homeowners Ask Me About Metal Roofs


"Is it noisy in the rain?" With proper solid decking and insulation underneath (which is standard on a real roofing job, not a garage retrofit), it's not noticeably louder than asphalt shingles. The "tin roof in a rainstorm" reputation mostly comes from metal installed directly over open rafters with no decking — barns and outbuildings, mostly.

"Can I install solar panels on it?" Standing seam is actually one of the easier roof types for solar, since many mounting systems clamp onto the seams without any roof penetrations at all. Screw-down panels need traditional penetrating mounts.

"Does it affect my homeowners insurance?" Often favorably — some insurers offer discounts for metal roofing because of the wind and hail resistance and fire rating. Worth a call to your agent either way.

"Can I walk on it?" Standing seam can typically be walked on carefully at the seams, not the flat panel areas. Screw-down panels are more forgiving underfoot but can still dent. I wouldn't recommend DIY roof work on either without knowing exactly where it's safe to step.


Bottom Line

A metal roof, done right, is one of the best long-term investments you can make in a Central New York home — this is a place where snow load and freeze-thaw cycling genuinely punish lesser roofing. But "metal roof" on a listing sheet isn't a guarantee of quality any more than "hardwood floors" is. The installation, the flashing details, and the underlayment underneath matter just as much as the panels on top.

If you're buying a home anywhere from Onondaga to Oswego to Jefferson County and it's got a metal roof, that's exactly the kind of detail I'll get up close to during your inspection — not just glance at from the driveway.


Golden Standard Services provides home inspections, septic inspections, and environmental testing throughout Central New York, including Onondaga, Cayuga, Cortland, Oswego, Madison, and Jefferson counties.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page